| #9 | Averett | (1,9) | -1.057 | -1.857 |
| #6 | Bridgewater VA | (4,6) | -0.975 | -1.175 |
| #8 | Gallaudet | (1,8) | -1.056 | -1.833 |
| #7 | Guilford | (2,8) | -1.144 | -1.744 |
| #2 | Hampden-Sydney | (7,3) | -1.062 | -0.662 |
| #1 | Randolph-Macon | (9,2) | -0.942 | -0.306 |
| #5 | Roanoke | (6,4) | -1.175 | -0.975 |
| #3 | Shenandoah | (8,3) | -1.175 | -0.721 |
| #4 | Washington & Lee | (7,4) | -1.006 | -0.734 |